U.S. Appeals Okays Law Enforcement Use of Stingrays Without Warrants


Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

sting ray 2Police departments will not need search warrants before using Stingrays to obtain tower and cell site information while tracking a suspect’s mobile phone. That’s the 12-3 ruling yesterday from the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The court in Richmond, VA held that the Fourth Amendment permits law-enforcement officials access to records created by service providers that show which cell towers mobile phones connect to when they are in use, the Wall Street Journal reported.

With the full bench of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals voting, the decision allows investigators to get the information under the legal theory that it has been disclosed to third parties — in such instances, telephone companies, Politico said.

“The Supreme Court may in the future limit, or even eliminate, the third-party doctrine. Congress may act to require a warrant for CSLI [cell site location information.] But without a change in controlling law, we cannot conclude that the Government violated the Fourth Amendment in this case,” Judge Diana Motz said, writing the court’s majority opinion.

In that opinion, Motz’s concluded that cellphone users expect providers to route outgoing and incoming calls and text messages.

“Whenever he expects his phone to work, he is permitting—indeed, requesting—his service provider to establish a connection between his phone and a nearby cell tower,” Motz wrote. “A cell phone user thus voluntarily conveys the information necessary.”

In its ruling, the Fourth Circuit falls in sync with three other regional appeals courts and means that law enforcement officers in Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia can obtain a court order for location data by showing merely that the records are relevant to an ongoing investigation, WSJ.com said. A warrant requires a showing of probable cause.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.